• Archive for May, 2009

  • LearnHub – International Online Education Lead Generation

    Comments

    Learnhub logo
    Earlier this year at LeadsCon Las Vegas 2009, I found myself having a quick conversation with John Green, co-founder CTO of LearnHub. Despite our introductory chat occurring during the after-party, I remember making a mental note to speak with him later about what sounded like a unique and interesting business from entrepreneur with relevant prior experience. At some point later, I remembered that mental note, but I thought that I must have forgotten the company name and/or URL, as I didn’t think the site matched the mental note I had made. After spending some time on the phone with John recently, I did indeed remember the site correctly, but the mistake I made initially was to confuse LearnHub for something else, something less interesting. The reason I believe is that while the homepage clearly explains what the site has to offer, it goes about it an understated manner. In other words, it is easy to think of it as one of many that are playing in the presumably crowded field of college preparation. My conversation with John and learning more about the origins of the people behind LearnHub convinced me that LearnHub is anything but a me too.

    The two founders of LearnHub, the husband and wife team of John Green and Malgosia Green, worked together at Affinity Labs prior to founding LearnHub. While Affinity Labs is known for its community approach to generating tremendous organic growth, lead generation provided the revenues, and that monetization engine is what John built. Capturing data for a single buyer isn’t all that complex, but managing that process for hundreds of buyers, each of whom has different requirements – not just the fields but what they call those fields and how they want the data delivered – takes a relatively simple task and makes it logarithmically more difficult one. And all of those are just backend processing functions. Any good platform also includes administrative interfaces so that non-technology users can interact with the system, which includes not just reporting functions so that the business can know where it stands at any given moment but also fraud settings and budgeting functions. A testament to the platform, it ultimately became the platform for all of Monster Learning, e.g., FastWeb, after their acquisition of Affinity Labs in 2006.

    John and Malgosia didn’t have plans to leave Affinity Labs, especially since they did so prior to its acquisition, but they found themselves on unexpectedly on the radar of Shantanu Prakash, the founder of Educomp Solutions Limited, India’s largest education company. The three of them began speaking, and those conversations along with their entrepreneurial bent formed the genesis of LearnHub. Today, the company is just over a year old, and while the founders are based in Toronto, they run a non-traditional multi-national company. Their primary investor is in India, software development and sales  is in Toronto (with an additional sales office in the US);  marketing, counseling, and community management is housed in India. That last part might not seem intuitive, but it is at the heart of their business. They began with a premise that there is a business in international lead generation for education – not the more obvious angle of trying to generate leads from non-US students for one of the handful of for-profit institutions with localized online programs. The bigger market and the one they wanted to make more efficient is that of foreign students traveling to the United States to obtain degrees. India is LearnHub’s largest market, for many reason, but it is the largest of the more than 50 countries from which they have generated leads.

    Drawing from their their Affinity Labs days, LearnHub has focused solely on organic traffic generation; that is why the site has gone deep into standardized testing and community functions designed to attract foreign students looking to study abroad. For those thinking they should get into this market, you might pause at the operational challenges involved. The usual suspects of lead buyers aren’t the ones looking for these leads. Almost 90% of LearnHub’s buyers hadn’t purchased leads prior to working withe company, and when dealing with a school, they are dealing with a different department, a different set of people and a different budget. That doesn’t include the work involved in getting an interested and qualified student enrolled. It’s not as simple as them beginning an online course; those don’t require visas. And, it makes their business all that more interesting that they have been able to become arguably the largest specializing in lead generation from one country to another. It also gives them a leg up for when it comes time to expand into other areas such as in-country lead generation and the promotion of related services, for their current clients are a complex customer in need of many additional services. All in all a great accomplishment with a lot less capital than the better known but less robust StudyPlaces.com (backed by Kleiner Perkins and Sherpalo Ventures), and it’s always great to see a company not just taking a me too approach to online lead generation.

    For the not so subtle plug, come see LearnHub at LeadsCon East 2009, August 17 – 18, 2009.

    Company Reviews
  • Challenges of Being A Small Lead Buyer

    Comments

    Our recent conversation with AllSeniorHomes, reminded me of another recent interaction, not with a lead generator but a lead buyer.  I was having breakfast with a friend and one of their friends. The friend of a friend turned out to own a boutique moving company specializing in moves from New York City to South Florida. For those familiar with their East Coast geography and the migratory behavior of a certain demographic, focusing on that particular route isn’t accidental. Anything but arbitrary, it’s a specialized product that attracts a very specific demographic. What surprised me though was learning that this small company supplements its referral business with the purchase of online leads – surprising because we often think of those fulfilling the higher end of the service spectrum as being unwilling to embrace lead generation. What I found more fascinating than the purchase of leads are the challenges they face in the ecosystem.

    Catch 22

    Just as the small to mid-size businesses make up a great percentage of the employers, they also make up a healthy percentage of the lead buyers. Certain areas of online lead generation, like online education, will have a disproportionate percentage of the leads going to a handful of buyers, but that isn’t the case in all verticals, not in auto insurance lead generation (for aggregators with a strong buyer network) and not in moving. The small lead buyers, just like any smaller quantity advertiser, can be a Catch-22. It takes a lot of small lead buyers to make up the volume of a larger lead buyer, and the smaller lead buyers tend to have two other disadvantages – a) they are harder to deal with because they are more sensitive to fluctuations in lead performance/behavior, and b) they tend to have less sophisticated systems for following-up with leads.

    It’s one thing to be a small lead buyer in a market full of just small lead buyers. It’s another to be a small lead buyer in a market where they receive the same lead as a larger, more institutionalized player. For that smaller player, a lag time of a day to get to a lead doesn’t necessarily seem like a bad thing. For a large buyer though, they often – either as a result of in-house efficiency or working with companies like Lead Qual or Double Positive – will have the phone ringing minutes after receipt of the lead. Were we speaking of just hot transfers, it would be different; instead we are focusing on just data leads. Here, the buyer is responsible for follow-up and management, and there is both challenge and opportunity. The challenge isn’t just competing to get to the lead quickly, it’s not having the staff. Unlike a large lead buyer, the small lead buyer doesn’t have a dedicated team to call on the leads. In the moving leads example, the owner of this highly lucrative company is the one who is getting on the phone and sending out emails. That’s not necessarily the best use of his time.

    I see opportunity in this, because the total number of small lead buyers is already significant, and more importantly, it’s just the tip of the iceberg compared to where will be in two, five, or even ten years. While we might have specialized software for certain industries, e.g. mortgage, to manage the leads they receive, there isn’t this robust platform for all types of lead buyers. Many moving lead buyers , for instance, license an industry specific CRM system. This system allows them to fire off automatic emails to the leads they purchase repeating much of what was captured – the date of the move, size, location. And, if the agent gets a lead on the phone, they can update that information centrally, and send out a revised email that can act closer to a contract. But, it’s a clunky system with much to be desired for the lead buyer and consumer.

    We will hopefully come to a point in time where there is an integrated system – lead management and analytics with modules that buyers can enable such as verification, scoring, and tapping an outside firm to translate data leads into hot transfers.  These are all things that the large buyers, but they have it only because they have had to built it or they have the savvy to integrate multiple different services. Just as Salesforce has transformed the way many sales people and sales organizations deal with their clients and prospects, so to will there come a time when a similar product can exist for those buying leads online. And, I can’t wait as strides are made because it will lower the barrier for buying leads and create a virtuous cycle of companies of all sizes using online lead generation.

    General Thoughts
  • AllSeniorHomes.com – Senior Housing Lead Generation

    Comments

    All Senior Homes

    Today I had the chance to speak with Jay Goldstein, one of the founding members of the recently launched, senior housing lead generation site AllSeniorHomes. Goldstein and his partners hail from another Seattle-based online lead generation firm, AllStarDirectories. The founding team knows a thing or two about the space, so it probably shouldn’t come as a surprise that their just public site shows great potential.

    Those visiting the home page, will find a clean layout with content around the major types of Senior Housing (think degree types if you are familiar with online education), including assisted living centers, nursing home centers, and retirement communities among others.  Below is a screenshot of the homepage. (Direct marketers will notice the well integrated search field that prompts users to enter the conversion funnel.)

    AllSeniorHomes - home page
    Senior care is an interesting are for lead generation and in many ways fits the desired economics companies look for in the space, namely price, market size, and potential buyers. First,  senior housing is an expensive product, costing tens of thousands per year on the low-end with a lifetime value for a customer often reaching into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. Second, the market size is substantial and only growing. In many ways, those exploring this space are early as the early baby boomers are still 10 years away on average from needing the service. Finally, senior housing centers are often run by  large holding companies, which means that from a lead sales perspective, a few key relationships can provide good coverage. (more…)

    Company Reviews
  • Scrub

    Comments

    Describes the percentage difference between a gross amount of data received and the net amount that is considered valid.  The scrub is a term commonly used when a party generating traffic is negotiating with a party buying that traffic. As the party generating the traffic receives payment for performance only, it will often want to minimize its exposure to potential loss and negotiate a maximum scrub. The scrub applies not just to lead buys, but was a commonplace discussion when two properties worked together and had their own tracking systems. With the advent of Google, the discussion in certain areas became moot as the advertiser paid what was recorded without any room for discrepancies. There, regardless of what the advertiser tracked, they paid what Google counted, with any disagreements having to go through a lengthy and not guaranteed process of seeking a return due to fraud. With both clicks and actions, the ultimate goal of the advertiser is to pay only for valid traffic, while the publisher wants to make sure they can charge for their work.

    Glossary
  • Link-Out

    Comments

    Used to describe a method for sending traffic from a third-party page, most commonly for non-standard arrangements. When a company advertisers via search or banners, it is common for that traffic source to send the user to the advertiser’s page. In these arrangements, there is an ad copy and a click through URL. The term Link-Out generally describes arrangements with sites that might want to collect the data themselves (see Hosted Landing Page), but one where the advertiser either is not set up or chooses not to accept direct posting on information. In those scenarios, when the site must send the user to the advertiser’s page for the conversion to take place, the term Link-Out is commonly used to describe that relationship.

    Glossary
  • Lead Validation/Verification

    Comments

    The term used when checking the details/data of any given lead, most usually with regards to contactability.  Prior to the concept of Lead Scoring coming into vogue, the main emphasis was on validation, i.e. verifying the lead data. Before the rise of internet-based lead generation, the main focus was on the validity of the postal address as most follow-up and advertising took place via postal mail. Companies receiving leads wanted to make sure they weren’t sending something to a non-existent address. The majority of online lead generation, on the other hand, relies not on the postal address but the phone number as that is where the follow-up takes place. As a result, the current focus is on mapping validity with intent. The classic assumption is that someone who entered valid data has a greater interest than someone who didn’t. Various services in the validation/verification space look to provide a rating or score of the validity of the data. This includes whether the address is a working address, whether the name entered matches the name of the resident at that address, if the phone number is working, what type of phone number, whether it matches the name entered, and so on. Perfectly matching data is not guarantee of intent, but it is a big start and essential especially for those selling leads and those buying leads who do not buy enough to use Lead Scoring.

    Glossary
  • Lead Scoring

    Comments Off

    A process that grew out of the lead validation / verification industry where leads receive a score suggestive of their likelihood to close. Lead Scoring is highly analytical and one of the more rapidly advancing industries as buyers of leads realize that not all leads are created equal. If a person buys just a handful of leads, scoring is not that important, but once a person/company starts to deal with resource allocation issues, i.e., who should work what leads and which leads do we make priorities, lead scoring can play an invaluable role. It is not magical though and requires a lead buyer to have kept records on past lead performance, namely what leads worked and what didn’t so that those in lead scoring can create a custom framework for them moving forward. For certain companies, lead scoring is used internally and then buyers allowed to purchase leads based on score; this application works well for small to medium buyers who don’t have enough lead data to use lead scoring services on their own lead data.

    Glossary
  • Lead Management

    Comments

    Describes systems that buyers use to maximize the leads they receive. In traditional sales organizations, software for managing prospects has long been employed and is a preferred way for employees and their managers to track progress. Lead Management is a similar concept involving specialized software to help lead buyers track their leads from purchase to close, with lead management systems integrating into other industry specific programs. Buyers who use some form of lead management system will close more business and find themselves spending more effectively, knowing which sources convert best.

    Glossary
  • Lead Delivery

    Comments

    Refers to mechanisms and processes used to receive the leads.  In the online lead generation business, generally a website collects the leads and then needs to send it to the buyer. The buyer’s level of sophistication will dictate how they wish to receive the lead. The major categories for transfer include real-time and batch. Real-time delivery means that once the lead is submitting the buyer receives it with no delay. Batch implies that the leads are collected and sent over in a bundle on some designated schedule. While real-time leads can include an email with the data, or in the very early days a fax, the majority of real-time leads are delivered via some method of posting, i.e., the data is sent in real time and entered into the buyers back-end.

    Glossary
  • Landing Page

    Comments

    A term used to refer to the page that a user sees after clicking on an ad. A landing page is relative. If the ad takes the person to the company’s homepage, then the homepage is the landing page. More often than not, specific pages are designed to be the landing page. This is done to increase the likelihood of conversion. Let’s use a travel example. If the ad talks about great European vacations, it makes sense to send the person to a page that talks about European vacations rather than sending them to the generic home page. Or, sub-optimally, if you send them to the homepage, make sure there is a clear call out for the European vacations. The same holds true with commerce. If the promotion talks about holiday savings, take the user to that content to increase the conversion rate.

    Glossary

  • LeadsCon
  • DoublePositive
  • LeadPoint
  • Ampush Media



  • Recent Comments:

    • Ken: Fascinating overview, Jay. I think it'll be unworkable for schools to track and report on how their former...
    • Max: Great summary Jonathan. It seems like so much talk in the lead gen space lately has been about the potential new...
    • FrankVendola: Sisco, The Department of Labor told me that we have to wait 15 days from the 1st to file a complaint. I...
    • Francisco_pool_shark: francisco was here ..what this company did is uncalled for and it should not be tolerated. i...
    • FrankVendola: Dr. Sanjaya Addanki,Ex-C.E.O. Innovation Ads233 Plaza Real, Boca Raton,Florida, USA415-420-0176 July 1,...